Cookout Shake Flavors: Top 40+ Delicious Mix & Match Options
Cookout Shake Flavors offer an incredible variety, with over 40 options to satisfy any craving. Fan favorites include Oreo Mint, Peanut Butter Fudge, and Strawberry Cheesecake, but the real fun comes from mixing flavors, allowing you to create unique combinations like Peanut Butter-Banana Fudge or Red Cherry-Peach. These shakes are known for their rich, creamy texture, often so thick they’re eaten with a spoon. Whether you’re a fan of classic tastes or adventurous blends, Cook Out’s milkshake menu has something for everyone.
Top Cookout Milkshake Flavors You Must Try in 2025
If you’re looking for the best Cookout milkshake flavors, here’s a list of fan favorites that you should definitely try:
- Banana Pudding: This shake is a Southern classic, with real banana flavor and pieces of vanilla wafers mixed in for an extra treat.
- Oreo Mint: A refreshing mix of minty flavor with crunchy Oreo bits, perfect for those who love mint chocolate desserts.
- Peanut Butter Fudge: Rich and nutty, this shake mixes creamy peanut butter with chocolate fudge for a decadent option.
- Peach Cobbler: This summer favorite blends sweet peaches with cobbler pieces, giving you a fruity and comforting dessert in a cup.
- Reese’s Cup: A top choice for chocolate and peanut butter lovers, blending real Reese’s Peanut Butter Cups for a smooth, candy-inspired shake.
- Strawberry Cheesecake: Combines the fresh taste of strawberries with creamy cheesecake, making it a must-try for fruity dessert fans.
- M&M: A fun and colorful shake that mixes M&M pieces into vanilla ice cream, adding a sweet crunch.
These are just some of the top flavors, but the great thing about Cookout is that you can mix and match flavors to create your own! Popular combinations include Peanut Butter Oreo or Banana Nut with Caramel. So next time you’re at Cookout, try one of these favorites or make your own unique blend!
All 40 Cookout Shakes Flavors in 2025
Classic Shakes
These timeless flavors are always a hit for their simplicity and deliciousness:
- Vanilla
- Chocolate
- Strawberry
These flavors are perfect for anyone who enjoys traditional milkshakes, made with real ice cream to deliver a smooth and creamy texture.
Banana-Inspired Shakes
Cookout offers an array of banana flavors that are popular due to their natural sweetness:
- Fresh Banana: Simple and refreshing.
- Banana Fudge: Adds a touch of rich chocolate to the banana base.
- Banana Pudding: A Southern favorite, this shake blends banana with the creamy richness of vanilla wafers.
- Banana Pineapple: Offers a tropical twist with the addition of pineapple.
Peanut Butter Lovers
If you love peanut butter, Cookout has plenty of indulgent options:
- Peanut Butter: Classic and rich.
- Peanut Butter Banana: A mix of creamy peanut butter and fruity banana.
- Peanut Butter Fudge: Combines peanut butter with rich chocolate fudge for an extra decadent treat.
Fruity Favorites
For those who prefer a lighter, fruity option, Cookout offers these refreshing choices:
- Peach: Tastes like summer in a cup.
- Blueberry: Full of juicy blueberry flavor.
- Pineapple: A tropical option perfect for warm weather.
- Red Cherry: Tart and sweet, a fan-favorite.
Chocolate Lovers’ Dream
Chocolate fans are spoiled for choice at Cookout:
- Hershey’s Chocolate
- Chocolate Malt
- Choc Chip Mint
- Chocolate Nut
- Chocolate Cherry
Each of these options delivers rich, creamy chocolate flavors combined with unique mix-ins like nuts, mint, or cherry, perfect for satisfying any chocolate craving.
Candy and Dessert-Inspired Shakes
For those who love candy, these shakes bring your favorite treats to life:
- Oreo: Creamy with crunchy Oreo bits.
- Reese’s Cup: Perfect for peanut butter and chocolate lovers.
- Snickers: Combines caramel, chocolate, and nuts.
- Butterfinger: Crunchy and chocolatey with the signature Butterfinger flavor.
- Heath Toffee: Offers a nutty, toffee flavor perfect for indulgence.
Specialty Flavors
Cookout offers unique milkshake options that you won’t find anywhere else:
- Orange Push-Up: A tangy orange flavor mixed with creamy ice cream, reminiscent of the popular frozen treat.
- Cheesecake (Multiple Flavors): You can choose from options like Blueberry Cheesecake, Strawberry Cheesecake, or even Chocolate Chip Cheesecake.
Coffee and Mocha Flavors
For coffee lovers, these shakes bring a delightful coffee-infused flavor:
- Cappuccino: Rich and creamy with a strong coffee taste, great for an energy boost.
- Mocha: A delicious blend of coffee and chocolate, offering the best of both worlds.
Caramel Flavors
Caramel-based shakes add a sweet, buttery richness:
- Caramel: Smooth and sweet with the rich flavor of caramel.
- Caramel Fudge: A deeper, richer version with added fudge for a chocolatey touch.
More Chocolate and Cookie Variants
Cookout offers even more chocolate-inspired varieties:
- Double Chocolate: Twice the chocolate for serious chocolate lovers.
- Chocolate Chip Cherry: A unique combo that pairs chocolate chips with tart cherry flavor.
- Chocolate Cherry: Perfect for those who love the blend of rich chocolate and sweet cherries.
- Choc Chip Mint: A refreshing mix of minty freshness with chocolate chips, similar to mint chocolate chip ice cream.
Nutty and Dessert-Inspired Shakes
Cookout doesn’t shy away from dessert-inspired and nutty shakes:
- Chocolate Nut: Combines the smoothness of chocolate with the crunch of nuts.
- Walnut: For those who love the buttery, slightly bitter flavor of walnuts.
Specialty Candy Shakes
These flavors bring some of your favorite candy bars to life in milkshake form:
- M&M®: A candy classic mixed into a smooth milkshake.
- Oreo®: The perfect balance of crunchy cookies and creamy ice cream.
- Oreo® Mint: Combines Oreo with a refreshing mint twist.
Seasonal Specials
Cookout has some shakes that are only available during certain times of the year:
- Fresh Watermelon: Available from July to August, this shake is light, refreshing, and captures the essence of summer.
- Fresh Eggnog: A holiday treat available in December, perfect for those who love the creamy, spiced flavor of traditional eggnog.
Unique and Fun Flavors
Finally, Cookout has a few flavors that stand out for their uniqueness:
- Orange Push-Up®: A refreshing citrus flavor reminiscent of a childhood favorite popsicle.
- Cheesecake (Blueberry, Caramel, Cherry, Chocolate Chip, Strawberry): These shakes combine the rich, creamy flavor of cheesecake with various fruit or candy mix-ins, making them a dessert lover’s dream.
Cookout Milkshakes Flavors Menu with Prices and Calories
| Milkshake Flavor | Price | Calories |
|---|---|---|
| Fresh Banana | $2.79 | 510 cal |
| Banana Berry | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Banana Fudge | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Banana Nut | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Banana Pineapple | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Banana Pudding | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Blueberry | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Butterfinger® | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Cappuccino | $2.79 | 560 cal |
| Caramel | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Caramel Fudge | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Cheesecake | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Fresh Watermelon (Seasonal) | $2.79 | 650 cal |
| Hershey’s® Chocolate | $2.79 | 620 cal |
| Chocolate (Double) | $2.79 | 650 cal |
| Chocolate Cherry | $2.79 | 670 cal |
| Choc Chip Cherry | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
| Choc Chip Mint | $2.79 | 830 cal |
| Chocolate Malt | $2.79 | 670 cal |
| Chocolate Nut | $2.79 | 750 cal |
| Heath® Toffee | $2.79 | 700 cal |
| M&M® | $2.79 | 755 cal |
| Mocha | $2.79 | 620 cal |
| Orange Push-Up® | $2.79 | 640 cal |
| Oreo® | $2.79 | 800 cal |
| Oreo® Mint | $2.79 | 850 cal |
| Peach | $2.79 | 550 cal |
| Peach Cobbler | $2.79 | 790 cal |
| Peanut Butter | $2.79 | 850 cal |
| Peanut Butter Banana | $2.79 | 860 cal |
| Peanut Butter Fudge | $2.79 | 770 cal |
| Pineapple | $2.79 | 580 cal |
| Red Cherry | $2.79 | 600 cal |
| Reese’s Cup® | $2.79 | 890 cal |
| Snickers® | $2.79 | 720 cal |
| Strawberry | $2.79 | 610 cal |
| Vanilla | $2.79 | 560 cal |
| Walnut | $2.79 | 850 cal |
| Fresh Eggnog (Seasonal) | $2.79 | 510-900 cal |
Notes:
- Each milkshake is priced at $2.79 across all locations.
- Calories vary depending on the flavor, ranging from 510 to 900 calories. Some of the heavier shakes, such as Reese’s Cup and Walnut, are on the higher end with up to 890 calories.
How to Customize Your Cookout Milkshake: Simple and Fun Options
At Cookout, you can create your perfect milkshake by mixing and matching flavors from their huge selection of over 40 milkshakes. Here’s how to make your own delicious combinations and some easy tips to get creative with your order.
1. Mix and Match Flavors
Cookout allows you to combine any flavors you want. For example, you can mix Peanut Butter with Oreo for a unique twist, or try combining fruity flavors like Peach and Red Cherry for a refreshing summer drink. Whether you like chocolatey, fruity, or nutty flavors, you can get creative with endless combinations.
2. Secret Customizations
Some Cookout locations offer special add-ons. You can ask for Nilla Wafers in your shake for a “cobbler-style” texture, or even add a slice of cheesecake for an extra indulgence. These hidden options make your milkshake even more unique.
3. Seasonal Flavors
Look out for seasonal shakes like Pumpkin Pie in the fall or Eggnog in December. These flavors add even more variety and excitement to your milkshake choices.
With so many flavors and customization options, Cookout makes it easy to create the perfect milkshake just for you. Every visit can be a new experience with endless combinations to try. So next time you’re at Cookout, mix and match your favorite flavors to make your dream milkshake!
Rating of Cookout Shakes Flavors
